Women in Transit

Publications and media coverage

Relevant Scientific Articles

This work uses a national index to examine differences in transport poverty between men and women in Canada. We calculated for each metropolitan area the average indices of social disadvantage, transport disadvantage, and transport poverty for men and women. Applying a paired t-test, we observe men have higher inaccessibility, women have higher marginalization, and overall a higher index of transport poverty. Using two metropolitan areas as case studies, we performed a local cluster analysis (LISA) to identify areas with spatial concentrations of transport poverty by gender.

Accessibility, the ease of interacting with potential opportunities, is an increasingly important tool among transport planners aiming to foster equitable and sustainable cities. However, in accessibility research there is a historical focus on employment destinations that is shaped by a masculinist transportation planning tradition. This paper aims to counter this gendered bias by connecting the Mobility of Care framework, a gender-aware transport planning conceptualisation to an empirical accessibility analysis of care destinations in the City of Hamilton, Canada. Care destinations are all the places one must visit to sustain household needs such shopping, errands, and caring for others. This paper considers access to care across different modes of transport at two travel time thresholds (trips shorter than 15-min and 30-min) using a curated care destination dataset. The accessibility methods used includes the cumulative opportunities measure and a competitive and singly-constrained accessibility measure (spatial availability) for different modes. Overall, results indicate that accessibility by car is exceptionally high across the city, while access by public transit, cycling and foot is relatively low with some exceptions in the inner city. Notably, there are distinctions between both methods: cumulative opportunities illustrates a more optimistic potential interaction landscape for non-car modes, while the spatial availability measure demonstrates a theoretically more realistic spatial distribution of care destination availability of potential interaction. Neighbourhoods with both low spatial availability to care and a high proportion of low-income households are also identified and discussed as areas in need of intervention. The manuscript and analysis is computationally reproducible and openly available. The presented analysis demonstrates methods planners can use to apply a gender-aware lens to accessibility analysis. Further, results can inform policies aiming to encourage sustainable mobility.

The concept ‘mobility of care’ captures all the daily travel necessary for the upkeep of a household, including trips to grocery stores, health-related appointments, errands, and caring activities for dependents. Since it was originally coined in 2009, a handful of studies have shown how poorly mobility of care trips are captured in transportation surveys. These preliminary analyses also find that care trips comprise a substantial proportion of daily mobility. As women disproportionately engage in ‘mobility of care’ travel, the under-consideration of care trips is argued to result in a gender bias in transport planning. Despite this, transport policy related to mobility of care has received less attention. Given that transport policy shapes how transport systems operate, this paper explores the extent to which recent transport policies consider mobility of care. A critical policy review framework is used to systematically examine seven policy documents (435 pages) from the Toronto Transit Commission (TTC), the largest transit agency in Canada. Results indicate that mobility of care is rarely directly considered or significantly discussed. Instead, transport policy often uses the commute to work as the default trip. Mentions of care destinations and trip characteristics associated with mobility of care are more common in recent years and most frequently discussed in relation to the COVID-19 pandemic or specialized services for seniors and people with disabilities. Policies that likely facilitate mobility of care indirectly are also identified, including fare discounts, transfer windows, and accessibility policies. The review concludes with preliminary recommendations on how transit agencies can more directly plan for mobility of care.

Transport and gender are intrinsically intertwined. However, traditionally, transport planning has tended to favor the travel needs of adult men in home-work trajectories, thereby ignoring women’s distinct experiences and needs. More recently, scholars have looked at the relationship between transport and gender, highlighting important discrepancies in travel behavior (e.g., mode, purpose, time of trip). Yet, thorough spatial analysis, especially for the Canadian context, remains scarce. This study examines the differences in spatial travel patterns between men and women in Montréal, Canada, using the 2018 Origin-Destination survey. First, the distance travelled by men and women is analyzed through descriptive statistics, and two distinct bootstrapped linear regression models are generated to identify key determinants of travel distance among women and men. Second, a ratio of the number of trips (women/men) ending in each census tract is generated to identify areas predominantly visited by women. A local spatial autocorrelation analysis is then performed. Findings show that women’s trips tend to be more local than men’s, possibly attributable to socio-cultural factors. Differences between gender are most visible among lower-income groups and in suburban areas, while the presence of children in the household reduces women’s distances more substantially than men’s. Significant spatial clusters were found for women and men, with distinct land use and transport characteristics. This research highlights the need for researchers and practitioners to consider gender differences in transport planning and can contribute to formulating and designing more equitable transport policy and systems for men and women.

Despite intentions to prioritize marginalized groups in transportation infrastructure planning, existing methodologies often fail to operationalize equity analysis empirically, largely due to insufficient disaggregated travel data by gender and other identity factors, coupled with the absence of accessible tools for analysis. Hence, the main objective of this study is to assess how an equity prioritization framework, such as Gender-Based Analysis (GBA) Plus, can be integrated into capital infrastructure planning to enhance inclusivity and equity in decision-making processes. The study develops and tests a novel methodology for assessing the impact of two proposed BRT corridors on equity-deserving groups, including women, seniors, youth, Indigenous peoples, immigrants, low-income individuals, and visible minorities. The proposed methodology integrates two analytical approaches: first, a local accessibility analysis, which examines the demographic profile of residents living near proposed corridors, considering their potential access and usage based on the proximity; and second, a regional accessibility analysis, which examines accessibility changes to destinations frequented by youth, seniors, women and people with disabilities, including work, shopping, dining, recreation, education, caregiving (such as escorting minors or seniors), healthcare facilities, and personal errands. Application of the methodology to a mid-sized Canadian city, Edmonton, reveals that both proposed BRT corridors will significantly benefit equity-deserving groups residing near the stops, and empirical gains in accessibility to high-demand opportunities are presented. The approach offers a scalable model for future route or corridor-level planning studies, providing a framework for assessing equity and accessibility across diverse identity groups.

While carsharing is used more by men than women, little is known about how gender shapes carsharing patterns. Accordingly, this study examines how gender shapes usage patterns. Using Montreal carsharing data, the study analyses distance, duration, and stops per reservation through descriptive statistics, regressions and gender-stratified models. Descriptive statistics show that women, compared to men, travel shorter distances, make fewer stops, yet spend more time per reservation. Multilevel regression analyses confirm these statistically significant gender differences. Women’s shorter distances and longer reservation times may lead to higher costs per kilometre under some pricing structures. Gender-stratified models reveal both gender-specific and shared patterns: women show varied suburban travel patterns, higher residential area income increases men’s distances compared to lower-income areas but has little effect on women’s distances, while both genders show similar temporal patterns. Findings underscore the need for continued research into equitable mobility systems across different contexts.

“Mobility of care” refers to the daily travel required to complete care labor such as travel to the grocery store, or to escort children. Though past research has examined the distribution of individual types of household-serving travel, little research to date, especially in the North American context, has examined mobility of care which combines all travel required to fulfill a household’s care needs. This paper presents the results of an exploratory analysis of mobility of care drawing on the 2018 Montreal Origin–Destination Survey. Specifically, this paper explores who completes this type of travel and how this mobility is completed. Findings indicate that mobility of care comprises 28% of adults’ daily mobility. Further, women are found to complete more of this type of travel than men, especially women from lower-income households. The presence of children in the household further widens this gendered gap, though the number of children present does not alter this trend greatly. Mobility of care trips are shorter on average than other types of travel and are frequently completed as part of a trip-chain. Further, car use and walking are more frequently used for mobility of care than other types of travel, while the opposite is true for public transport and cycling. The use of public transport for mobility of care trips is greater amongst women than men, especially those living in lower-income households. Taken together, results highlight the importance for practitioners to explicitly address mobility of care in transport planning, and particularly in public transport planning.

Media Coverage

Exciting updates are on the way!
peter lawrence rxza4ufjogw unsplash
Scroll to Top